Posts

Showing posts with the label Persian

Final partThis strengthens credibility and keeps the article evergreen.AppendixFrequently Asked Questions (FAQs)1. Is there any historical source that mentions 30,000 Brahmins at Karbala?No.There is no reliable primary or secondary historical source—Islamic, Persian, Indian, or neutral—that records such participation. Early chroniclers describe a small group of

Image
Final part This strengthens credibility and keeps the article evergreen. Appendix Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) 1. Is there any historical source that mentions 30,000 Brahmins at Karbala? No. There is no reliable primary or secondary historical source—Islamic, Persian, Indian, or neutral—that records such participation. Early chroniclers describe a small group of companions, not mass armies. 2. Does denying this claim disrespect Hussaini (Hoseni) Brahmins? Not at all. Correcting historical exaggeration does not deny cultural reverence. Hussaini Brahmins are respected for their ethical and spiritual association, not for battlefield presence. 3. Then why do many people firmly believe this story? Because: It has been repeated emotionally in speeches and videos It serves modern ideas of unity and pride Oral traditions tend to expand over generations Repetition creates familiarity, and familiarity often gets mistaken for proof. 4. Were non-Muslims influenced by Karbala histo...